Can You Spot the Fake News Story?
This week in library lessons our Year 7 & 8 students (ages 11-12) are taking part in a quick, relaxed lesson on real and fake stories.
Here is how I run it:
I have a copy of Ripley's Believe it or Not! All True! All Weird! All New! 2024 but any Ripley's or fact book would work.
Students are sat at 8 tables, there are 3-4 students per table.
Each table receives a different story.
7 of these stories are true.
1 of these stories is false.
Where do I get the false story?
I chose this one about a popular theme park here in the UK selling off shoes that have fallen off ride-goers. However you can choose any fake news story that sounds legit.
I explain to the group that their task is to work out which story in the room is the fake one.
Before we start, I go over the red flags that make up a fake news story
When I say "go" each table gets 2 minutes with their story, which is very short and easy to read. I usually get one person from each group to read their story to the table.
After the 2 minutes is up the tables rotate their stories to the next table. This takes around 20 minutes.
When all tables have had a chance to digest all of the stories, I give them another 2 minutes to create their final answer.
I also include the teacher in this and get them to choose.
When the last 2 minutes is up, each group announces their answer and provides a reason why.
The groups that have chosen correctly have had some very insightful comments, which include:
Theme park rides usually stop when shoes come off.
Why would ride-goers go home with only one shoe, they'd demand to find their lost shoe.
Not many people would buy one shoe even at a reduced price.
Some of the students have been to the park in question and felt that they would have seen such this shoe shop.
Why would a theme park bother with making such little money on lost shoes when they could focus on making much more money on rides and food etc.
Overall, it's been a really fun and easy way to get them to think critically, have fun and consider carefully the information that they are presented with.
At the time of writing this, only around 30% of students have been able to correctly identify the one fake story out of the bunch.



Comments
Post a Comment